The Record

Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

Becca Siegel

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The fall HMTC production, “The Rappaccini Variations,” has generated controversy recently regarding its usage of Noh, a type of Japanese theatre.

“The Rappaccini Variations,” uses a combination of different theatre styles, such as Noh, to narrate Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short story “Rappaccini’s Daughter.”

Noh theatre originated in 14th-century Japan and centers around the discussion of life after death, and in the context of “The Rappaccini’s Variations,” a ghost’s decision to stay in or depart the material world.

For the Noh scene of the play, Bebe Steel (11) and Sarah Sun (9) wear traditional shozoku (a style of silk robe), wigs, and masks. The controversy lies in the masks’ appearance, which in traditional Noh style, are painted to represent Japanese faces. The masks have overly-exaggerated yellow skin and small eye-holes, actress in “The Rappaccini Variations” Allison Li (12) said.

Members of the cast, such as Li, have been upset with the costume department’s decision to place actors in copies of the traditional Noh masks, as they resemble yellow-face, Li said.

The conflict was first noticed by Binah Schatsky (12) and Steel, upon viewing the masks during last Friday’s dress rehearsal. Both initially saw the possible controversy, but Steel felt that the masks would be a crucial part to appreciating the Noh customs properly, Steel said.

The play’s company had a meeting this past Saturday morning to discuss the issue, calling in Director of Office for Identity, Culture and Institutional Equity (ICIE) Patricia Zuroski to advise them on changes that could be made to the script or costumes to avoid offending members of the school’s community.

The usage of Noh theater was meant to introduce viewers to a complex Japanese tradition, rather than cause offense, Timko said.

“I can see where the controversy stems from, but we are trying to appreciate the style of theatre and spread its influence to students who might not have had experience with it before,” Steel said.

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

    Arts & Entertainment

    Pen to Paper: Potamopoulou creates graphic novel

  • Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

    Arts & Entertainment

    HM 246 presents gallery to Bronx community

  • Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

    Arts & Entertainment

    Spring MD/UD Concert provides space for music and reflection

  • Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

    Arts & Entertainment

    The One Acts: The Girl with Kaleidoscope Eyes

  • Arts & Entertainment

    Music Week Preview

  • Arts & Entertainment

    Student-Written One-Act Festival preview

  • Arts & Entertainment

    Annual Asia night celebrates culture

  • Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

    Arts & Entertainment

    SPOTLIGHT: Sheila Ferri, Lower Division Art Teacher

  • Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

    Arts & Entertainment

    BEHIND-THE-SCENES: Interview with Dance Co-Presidents Lauren Smith (12) and Juli Moreira (11)

  • Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy

    Arts & Entertainment

    Horace Mann Dance Company presents… Emotion in Motion

Horace Mann's Weekly Newspaper Since 1903
Rappaccini Variations: Japanese Noh Theatre Controversy